
The word "club" is never sung (or sing-sung) in Britney Spears' new single "Hold It Against Me." That would be redundant. By now it is a given that if you are pushing a pulsating pop-house track to a contemporary audience, you (and your narrator) are doing it from the club. Britney watches her object of lust from across the room, her favorite song is on, but she's looking to escape the crowd (unlike her contemporaries, she's not about to stick around, toss off unspecific observations about it and call it a day). Brit's lyrics are not special from any poetic standpoint, but they are remarkable within the context of pop. I predict that "Against" is as close to cutting the crap as popular dance music will get all year.
Britney's no vocal interpreter (the most character we hear from her here comes when she intones "hayzayyyy!"), but there is something wonderfully synergistic about the way she's performing on this track. Her social aggression ("Hey! Over there! Please forgive me! If I'm coming on too strong!") is met by a backing track of appropriately aggressive mechanical pounding and grinding, and further confirmed by Brit's bellowing (or at least whatever she can muster that approximates bellowing). Bravado trumps melody until the chorus, where the beat falls out, Brit's doe eyes grow three sizes and the desperation at the heart of her boldness is revealed: "If I said my heart was beating loud / If we could escape the crowd somehow / If I said I want your body now / Would you hold it against me?" (She's a woman, but not yet not a girl, too.) The lines that follow are hilarious in that they make me wonder if Calgon would serve as a backup plan should this dude reject her ("‘Cause you feel like paradise / And I need a vacation tonight!”), but what fun would listening to Britney Spears be if it didn't involve laughing at her at some point?
Her purring and cooing during the mind-wobbling dubstep breakdown is no joke, though -- she injects this dabbling in that genre with a sexiness that is so foreign, it makes sense that it's coming from an American. The breakdown itself is a gutsy move, as it introduces an unfamiliar, lopsided rhythm to both the track itself and much of Britney's listening audience outside of the UK. It's just one of several thrilling dynamic shifts in this instant classic. I love the half-time beats that come after the dubstep. The chorus breakdowns, build-ups and Matrix-like segues of hang time are tried-and-true methods of manipulation, but that makes them no less thrilling, just as a roller coaster taking its time to climb to a peak makes the subsequent drop no less thrilling. When the song leaves the aforementioned half-time breakdown to come crashing back in for one last chorus, paradise is found.
Britney's songs usually take some listens to get used to -- they tend to be weirdly specific and thus anti-anthemic ("Womanizer" may be an exception, but it'd be more universal, for example, were it about womanizers). "Hold It Against Me" upholds this lyrical tendency (it's seriously about a dude she sees that she likes, the end) but everything besides the lyrics makes "Against" an epic anthem despite itself. There hasn't been a time since the disco era that dance songs have been as commercially viable (and thus abundant) as they are now, and yet there's come to be so much uniformity in lyrics and sound that the form has become about as boring as being in an actual club (I'm sorry, it's true!). "Hold It Against Me" is exciting within itself (I'd love to hear what twists and turns this endlessly changing thing would take were it extended by a few minutes) and within pop music, period. As long as we get a track like this here and there to break up the tedium, the Great Dance Music Renaissance lives. All hail the queen?